The 8 Best Insurance Agencies in Frankenmuth, MI

Emil Rummel Insurance Agency Inc

Insurance agency

A 4.9 Google rating across 386 reviews helps earn Emil Rummel Insurance Agency Inc the top spot in Frankenmuth, MI. The independent agency handles personal and business insurance, emphasizing close work with clients to support informed coverage decisions. Positive review excerpts describe consistently good service and experiences with an agent. At 522 S Main St, the office offers online appointments and onsite services, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. Weekday hours of 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. provide a regular window for assistance.

• Independent insurance agency
• Online appointments available
• Personal and business

“I have always received fantastic service from you and I am a very happy customer!”

R.A. Monk Insurance Agency

Insurance agency

Offering insurance in Michigan since 1967, R.A. Monk Insurance Agency earns the No. 2 spot with a broad coverage lineup and a 4.9 Google rating from 80 reviews. At 464 N Franklin St in Frankenmuth, MI, the agency handles auto, homeowners, renters, and recreational vehicle coverage alongside business policies, professional liability, and workers compensation. One reviewer praised a timely quote and a quick, easy transfer. Online appointments, onsite services, and wheelchair-accessible parking and entry add practical convenience.

• Personal and business
• Online appointments
• Accessible entrance

“Had amazing timely quote and very quick and easy transfer !!!”

Farmers Insurance-Danielle Welch Agency

Insurance agency

Responsive follow-ups and patient coverage discussions help Farmers Insurance-Danielle Welch Agency earn rank 3 in Frankenmuth, MI. Reviewers describe help weighing coverage and affordability, finding life insurance, and resolving insurance issues with clear communication. The agency lists home, auto, life, and commercial insurance among its specialties, serving both personal and business needs. Its 5-star Google rating comes from 16 reviews. The East Jefferson Street office also offers weekday hours from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking.

• Responsive follow-ups
• Personal and business coverage
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“Josh took the time with me to review our insurance for coverage and affordability. He was very responsive with his follow ups.”

Roy Insurance Group - Farm Bureau Insurance

Insurance agency

Friendly, helpful service gives Roy Insurance Group - Farm Bureau Insurance a clear reason for its No. 4 spot. The agency holds a 4.7-star Google rating from 11 reviews, with supplied reviewers praising customer service, prices, and the convenient location. Its office at 718 W Genesee St in Frankenmuth, MI is open Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. A wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible parking add practical details for readers planning an office visit.

• Helpful staff
• Weekday office hours
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“The customer service has gotten even better with the addition of Ryan and Riley working here now!”

Rummel Benefits Group, Co.

Insurance broker

Helpful answers, attention to detail and patient plan selection earn Rummel Benefits Group, Co. the No. 5 spot. Reviewers describe responsive service and excellent advice, with one crediting the agency for helping choose an affordable insurance plan suited to her family. Its Google rating is 5 stars from three reviews. Located at 522 S Main St in Frankenmuth, MI, the agency focuses on insurance and employee benefits. Appointments are required, with online appointments and onsite services available Monday through Friday, 8 a.m.–5 p.m.

• Responsive service
• Online appointments
• Employee benefits focus

“The Rummel Benefits Group is very helpful and responsive to our questions and needs.”

Conzelmann Insurance Agency

Auto insurance agency

Help finding affordable coverage earns Conzelmann Insurance Agency the No. 6 spot in Frankenmuth, MI. One reviewer describes the agency helping his wife obtain coverage through Obamacare after losing Medicaid, praising its effort to find an affordable option. The agency has a 4.5 Google rating from two reviews. Its office at 1055 S Main St, Unit C, has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking. Listed hours are Monday through Thursday, 9 a.m.–5 p.m., and Friday, 9 a.m.–noon.

• Affordable coverage help
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance
• Wheelchair-accessible parking

“If there is affordable insurance out there for you, they're going to find it. My wife lost her insurance through Medicaid. We now have insurance for her 10 times better through Obama care. With the financial help we get through the gover…”

My Member Insurance Agency

Insurance agency

An independent agency with an appointment-only format, My Member Insurance Agency takes the seventh spot for its documented local presence and accessibility features. Its office is at 580 N Main St in Frankenmuth, MI, with both a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible parking. Plan to arrange an appointment rather than stop in for a walk-in visit. Those practical details make its location and visit requirements straightforward for anyone planning to meet with the agency.

• Independent insurance agency
• Appointment-only visits
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Frankenmuth Insurance

Insurance agency

Business, home, and auto coverage, plus surety bonds, give Frankenmuth Insurance a broad offering behind its No. 9 placement. Headquartered at 1 Mutual Ave in Frankenmuth, MI, it works exclusively through more than 800 independent agencies. The company reports an AM Best A (Excellent) Financial Strength Rating. Its Google rating is 3.3 stars across 413 reviews: positive accounts praise fair, prompt adjusters and help replacing a storm-damaged roof, while negative accounts describe policy cancellations and account-handling problems.

• Broad coverage options
• Independent agency network
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance

“Allowed a person no longer on my polo to file a claim add her boyfriend and take over my account this was beyond unacceptable I called and tried to stop the process and you still went through I have all paperwork and no one listen to me.”